Another New Florida Homeowners Insurance Late Notice Case: Hope and Cunningham v. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation


First Party Property Insurance Blog is Proud to Announce our New E-Book: the Florida Homeowners Insurance Claims and Litigation Handbook.

You know I am always here to provide tons of value to businesses in the insurance claims industry. We spent years collecting and analyzing leading industry data, strategies, action steps, and cases to know for our clients. We decided to make this available exclusively to the First Party Property Insurance Blog Community.

In this 99 page book, we provide our readers with:

  • the 16 Strategies You Need to Know to Master Florida Homeowners Insurance Claims, including pages of Action Steps and Cases to Know for evaluating each strategy
  • the 6 Key Statutes You Need to Know to Master Florida Homeowners Insurance Claims, including Practice Tips and Cases to Know for handling each statute
  • The 3 Tools You Need in Your Florida Homeowners Insurance Claims Toolbox, including our Resources, Legal Document Library, and Affirmative Defenses analysis, and
  • our CaseGlide Florida Homeowners Insurance Databases with insurer data, attorneys, and public adjusters

We’ve been conducting Webinars and Training Sessions on this material for years, and they have always helped our clients’ businesses. The Florida Homeowners Insurance Claims and Litigation Handbook has everything you need to help your colleagues, staff, and partners master our claims industry. Our clients have used the material in this E-Book to revolutionize how they handle claims and litigation.

We’re so confident in this E-Book that we offer you a money-back guarantee if it does not have the information you and your insurance claims business needed to improve. Click the image of the E-Book now to buy it for your friends and clients today.


Add to CartView Cart


*April 30, 2014: There are some other late notice cases that can help you prepare your case.  Check this link to make sure you review all of the late notice cases that have recently came out.*

LATE NOTICE CASE: HOPE & CUNNINGHAM V. CITIZENS

The Third DCA just issued the latest opinion on the late notice defense:

http://www.3dca.flcourts.org/opinions/3D11-3147.pdf

As discussed in Florida Courts on the Prompt Notice Provision and New Late Notice Case, the Florida DCAs have been giving insureds and insurers a lot to work with in terms of evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of a late notice defense.

The Third DCA’s opinion in Hope & Cunningham v. Citizens changes nothing in the current late notice law, but helps to maintain the status quo. The case involved a October, 2005 Hurricane Wilma claim reported to Citizens in 2009.

The Third DCA used the “tipsy coachmen doctrine,”which allows an appellate court to affirm a trial court’s order even if the trial court made the decision for the wrong reason. The trial court granted summary judgment pursuant to the Fourth DCA’s finding in Kroener v. FIGA that the passage of two years alone was sufficient for summary judgment on the defense, without consideration of the facts that might have overcome the presumption of prejudice.

The Third DCA said the trial court should have reviewed the plaintiff’s affidavit, the public adjuster’s report, and the roofer’s estimate to assess whether those could be sufficient to create a question of fact as to whether the plaintiffs could overcome the presumption of prejudice. The Third DCA took up that task and said that, because the evidence was merely conclusory, it did nothing to create a question of fact as to the prejudice. Accordingly, the Third DCA found that the trial court was right for the wrong reasons and Citizens was entitled to summary judgment.

This fits right in the prior analysis. Insureds must produce sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption of prejudice and the people presenting that evidence must stick to their stories. If an insured does not present evidence with specific (not conclusory), unwavering reasons as to why the insurer was not prejudiced, then summary judgment is proper.


Getting Started

New to the First Party Property Insurance Blog? Take five minutes to find the answers to your insurance questions by clicking here.


Did this Article Answer Your Homeowners Insurance Question?

If not, then go to our Getting Started page by clicking here, where we have a guide with easy-to-find links to the laws, cases, and articles that will answer your question, or contact me.

Name (required)

Email (required)

Phone Number

Comment

captcha